top of page

Is The Pressure to "Celebrate a Life" Helpful?

2 minutes ago
10 min read

Since I started PostScript, I've had the rare privilege of stepping into the most intimate corners of people’s lives. I sit (sometimes virtually) with widows, sons, daughters, and friends in the quiet days before a funeral, tasked with distilling a lifetime of their loved one into a ten-minute eulogy. It is a profound honour for sure, but I also recognise it is sometimes a front-row seat to a very specific, very different kind of pressure; the pressure to "celebrate a life", even when that life was often complicated.


I imagine most of us hear that phrase “celebration of life” a lot when someone dies. That's probably because it sounds warm, positive and reassuring, just when those qualities are needed the most. The phrase suggests that, although we are mourning the loss of someone we love, we should focus on everything that was wonderful about them, remember the good times and celebrate the life they lived. Easy right?


Of course, there can be enormous comfort in doing exactly that, but what happens when you just don't feel like celebrating?


What if your relationship with the person who died was more complicated? What if they hurt you or disappointed you? What if they struggled with addiction, were difficult to be around, or simply weren't the wonderful person that everyone else seems to remember? What if you loved them deeply but also had difficult feelings towards them?


Alternatively, what if you are simply too devastated by their death to feel remotely celebratory?


There can be an enormous amount of pressure surrounding bereavement to “celebrate a life”. Sometimes that pressure comes from family and friends. Sometimes it comes from the language used around modern funerals and sometimes, perhaps most powerfully, it comes from ourselves.

Red balloon with LIFE in black text floating against a solid red background, giving a bold, minimalist look
Original photo by Maria Oswalt on Unsplash. Edited with a filter.

Is The Pressure to "Celebrate a Life" Helpful?

As a professional eulogy writer and working with clients for the last two years of so, I believe it is worth asking whether celebrating a life is always the most helpful thing for someone who is grieving, so let's do just that.


The Tyranny of the "Perfect" Tribute

When I first speak with a family, there is often a palpable anxiety in the room. They want the eulogy to be "perfect". For many, "perfect" really means a sanitised version of events. They want to erase the heated arguments, the addictions, the estrangements, or the quiet cruelties that may have defined the relationship.


I frequently hear phrases like, "Just say he was a family man", or "She had a heart of gold". These are not lies necessarily, but they are often incomplete truths. The pressure to present a flawless narrative is immense. We fear that acknowledging the shadows will somehow disrespect the deceased.


However, this pressure to celebrate - to paint a picture of a modern-day saint where a human being once stood - can have a detrimental effect on the grieving process. Grief is not one thing. It is not just sadness. It is also anger, relief, regret, and confusion, often all at once.


When we force this narrative of pure celebration, we implicitly tell the bereaved that their complex feelings are unwelcome. We ask them to put on a mask of joy while their heart is breaking, or worse, while their heart is conflicted. That can't be helpful.


A Funeral Doesn't Have To Be A Celebration

The idea of celebrating someone's life is not inherently wrong. Remembering happy memories, sharing stories and acknowledging someone's achievements can be deeply comforting for those left behind, but a funeral is also an opportunity to acknowledge that someone has died.


I think that distinction matters.


As I just touched upon, grief isn't necessarily positive, uplifting or celebratory. It can be painful, angry, confusing, frightening, lonely and exhausting. It can contain relief alongside sadness. It can contain resentment alongside love. It can involve feelings that don't fit neatly into the idea of a “celebration”.


Don't get me wrong, there is no requirement for you to turn those emotions into something more palatable simply because other people would prefer a happier funeral. Sometimes the most honest funeral is not one where everyone spends an hour talking about how wonderful the deceased was. Sometimes it is one that simply acknowledges that this was a significant person whose death has changed people's lives.


What If They Weren't Always Easy To Love?

This is probably one of the most difficult situations I encounter when writing a eulogy for clients. To put it in simple terms, people are complicated.


Someone can have been a devoted parent but a difficult partner. They might have been generous to their friends but unreliable with their family. They could have achieved remarkable things while simultaneously causing considerable pain to the people closest to them.


Perhaps they struggled with alcohol or drugs. Perhaps there was a family breakdown. Perhaps there was abuse, neglect, infidelity, estrangement or years of unresolved conflict.


Death does not automatically erase any of that. Nor does it mean that everyone suddenly has to feel the same way about the person.


There is sometimes an unspoken expectation that, once someone has died, we should put all negative feelings aside. “Don't speak ill of the dead” is a familiar sentiment you'll hear, but grief doesn't work according to these simple rules. You cannot necessarily switch off decades of complicated emotions because someone has died.


That doesn't mean a funeral should become an opportunity to settle old scores, but I think there is an important difference between honesty and deliberately causing further hurt. There should also be room for emotional truth.


The Pressure to Perform Grief

There is another problem with the idea of celebrating a life in that it can create pressure to perform grief in a particular way. You might feel that you are expected to stand up and deliver a warm, affectionate eulogy filled with funny stories and happy memories.


Sounds good, but what if you don't have those memories? Or what if you do, but you can't access them because you are overwhelmed with grief? What if everyone else seems to be coping while you are struggling simply to get through the day?


I think we can all agree that with these contrary emotions, funerals can be strange environments at times.


There may be dozens or hundreds of people present, each with their own relationship with the person who has died. One person may remember a much-loved grandfather. Another remembers a work colleague of twenty years. Someone else remembers a complicated parent.


They have all lost the same person, but they haven't necessarily lost the same relationship. Expecting everyone to experience that loss in the same way is just unrealistic.


You Are Allowed To Grieve the Relationship You Actually Had

One of the most useful things you can do, and something that's too easily disregarded, is to give yourself permission to acknowledge the reality of your relationship with the deceased.


That might mean saying something like “I loved them, but we had our difficulties”, or

“I am devastated that they're gone, but there were things between us that were never resolved”. It could be more akin to “I have wonderful memories, but I also have painful ones” or “I miss them, but I don't miss everything about our relationship”.


These statements are not disrespectful. They are human.


Grief can become particularly complicated when we feel that we are not allowed to acknowledge these contradictions. You may end up grieving not only the person who died, but also the relationship you wished you had with them. That can be an especially difficult form of loss.

So What Should a Eulogy Actually Do?

I've said it many times, but a eulogy doesn't have to provide a complete biography. It doesn't have to prove that someone was perfect, and it certainly doesn't have to persuade everyone in the room that the deceased was universally loved. Its purpose is to acknowledge a life and the impact that life had.


Sometimes that can be done through a collection of positive memories. Sometimes it requires more subtlety.


If the person was complicated, you might focus on the qualities that genuinely mattered to the people present. You can recognise achievements without pretending there were no failures. You can tell a funny story without suggesting the person was always funny. You can talk about love without pretending the relationship was uncomplicated.


There is a great deal of freedom between a glowing tribute and a brutal assessment.

I strongly believe that middle ground is often where an honest eulogy lives.


Don't Let Somebody Else's Grief Dictate Yours

Of course, we're all different, as are those closest to us. As such, family dynamics can make grieving particularly difficult.


I've worked with many clients where one relative might insist that the funeral must be a celebration. Another may want religious readings. Someone else may want lots of photographs and upbeat music. Someone may even object to a particular story because they don't want people remembering the deceased in that way. In reality, some compromise will inevitably be necessary, particularly when arranging a funeral together.


It's important to remember that you don't have to adopt somebody else's emotional response.


Your sister might want to talk about your mother's achievements. You might be mourning the mother you never really had. Your brother might want to remember your father's sense of humour, whereas you might still be angry about something he did years ago. Both experiences can exist at the same time.


How Can You Take Some of the Pressure Away?

In my experience, I think the first step is to stop asking yourself what you are “supposed” to feel. Instead, ask yourself what you actually feel.


Writing things down privately can help. You don't have to show anyone, but write the good memories, the difficult memories, the things you miss, the things you don't miss and the things you wish had been different. You may find that your feelings are contradictory. Don't worry, that's perfectly normal.


It can also help to separate the private grieving process from the public funeral.

Despite what social media tells us, you don't have to tell everyone everything.


A funeral is not necessarily the appropriate place to disclose deeply personal family history, unresolved trauma or painful secrets. You can acknowledge complexity without putting every detail into a eulogy.


Equally, you don't have to manufacture a fictional version of the person. Find the truth that is appropriate for the people who will be listening.


Talk to Someone Who Understands The Complexity

If you're struggling to write a eulogy because you don't know how to reconcile conflicting feelings, talking to someone outside the family can be surprisingly helpful.


A professional eulogy writer (like me) will provide a degree of emotional distance that family members sometimes cannot. I firmly believe my role is not to tell you how you should feel about the person who died. It is to listen, understand the relationship and help you find the words that feel truthful and appropriate.


That might mean helping you identify the memories that genuinely deserve to be included. It might mean finding a respectful way to acknowledge a complicated life. Or it might simply mean taking away the burden of having to construct a eulogy while you are trying to cope with your own grief.


At the end of the day, you don't have to pretend that everything was perfect. Relationships rarely are.


There Is No “Right” Way to Celebrate a Life

As I bring this blog to a close, perhaps the most important thing to remember is that there is no single correct way to remember someone.


For some people, a celebration of life will be exactly what they need. Stories will be told, laughter will be shared and happy memories will provide a welcome moment of light during an incredibly difficult time.


For others, that approach may feel completely wrong. They may need a quiet funeral. They may need tears. They may need honesty. They may need to acknowledge the complicated parts of a relationship. They may simply need permission to say goodbye without having to turn the occasion into a celebration.


All of those responses, and everything in between, can be equally valid. A person's death does not require you to rewrite their entire life. Nor does it require you to rewrite your own experience of knowing them. Grief is difficult enough without adding the pressure of getting it “right”.


If you are struggling to write a eulogy because your feelings about the person who died are complicated, you don't have to navigate that alone. I can help you work through the memories, emotions and difficult decisions about what to include, creating a eulogy that is respectful, appropriate and, most importantly, authentic to the person you knew.


The PostScript

Is it always helpful to celebrate a life? No, at least not if "celebrate" means "pretend." It is helpful to remember a life. It is helpful to acknowledge a life, but the pressure to force a smile where a frown belongs is a heavy burden that no grieving person should have to carry.


Grief is messy. It is complicated... and it is yours. Whether you are planning a funeral for a beloved parent or a difficult partner, you deserve to do it in a way that allows you to breathe. You deserve a tribute that tells the truth, so that you can begin the long, hard work of healing.


At the end of the day, perhaps the greatest tribute we can give someone isn't to pretend they were perfect. It is to remember them honestly, with all the warmth, complexity, love, frustration, humour, sadness and humanity that made them who they were.


If you need help finding that truth, or simply finding the strength to put pen to paper, please get in touch and let's at least have a conversation. I am here to listen, and I am here to help you find the right words, for whatever kind of life it was.

Thanks so much for taking the time to read this blog. If it's a situation in which you find yourself, I hope it helped you. If not, I hope it at least helped pass a few minutes and kept you entertained. I'd love to know your thoughts. Do you think the need to celebrate a life is helpful? How would you want those you leave behind to honour you? Please leave a comment below and let me know; I read and reply to all of them.


If you do need help with a eulogy you've already written and maybe it just needs a professional polish, please click the link below. I'd be honoured to help.

Edit Your Eulogy
Buy Now

Finally, if you did enjoy this blog, please click the '❤️' below and feel free to share it on your socials. Maybe someone in your own network might need to read it without you realising. There are other relevant blogs you might like linked below, and 110 others on the site to enjoy. Thanks again, and take care.

Comments


bottom of page